Chapter 3: The Inner Struggle of Faith and Expectation

Many people think that anxiety and panic disorders are often to stem from isolated moments of crisis. However, they frequently develop over time, rooted in our environments, expectations, and beliefs that shape us. For me, (Philip Morgan), growing up in a conservative Christian community, I found that the comfort of faith was often accompanied by the weight of heavy expectations and rigid standards. These pressures became fertile ground for my anxiety to grow, slowly but steadily.

By sharing this chapter of my life, I aim to shed light on how the very systems that offered me solace also constrained me. My hope is to raise awareness about the need to address the deeper roots of anxiety—such as internalized shame, rigid expectations, and self-judgment—rather than merely managing symptoms. True healing comes when we confront these underlying causes and learn to embrace our humanity fully.

Faith can be both a refuge and a source of struggle. Growing up in a conservative Christian community, my faith gave me comfort, grounding, and a shared identity that connected me to others. It was a sanctuary in many ways, offering purpose and a sense of belonging. But alongside these gifts came immense pressure—expectations to embody perfection, uphold rigid ideals, and suppress doubts or vulnerabilities.

This chapter explores the dual nature of faith as both comfort and constraint. It delves into how the teachings of my community instilled in me a sense of moral superiority, while also fostering a relentless fear of failure and judgment. By tracing the roots of these experiences, I aim to shed light on how rigid expectations and self-judgment can intertwine with faith, ultimately contributing to anxiety. My hope is to offer a nuanced perspective on the ways in which faith can shape not only our beliefs but also our inner struggles.

I grew up in a conservative Christian community, where my faith was both a sanctuary and a source of pressure. It gave me a sense of belonging and purpose, grounding me in practices that offered spiritual comfort: prayer, devotion to scripture, and a shared identity with others in my community. Yet, alongside these gifts came the weight of expectation—a burden that would later feed the very anxiety I sought solace from.

Within this tight-knit community, the teachings of our faith were not merely spiritual guidelines; they were absolute truths. I was taught that we, as a group, were better as we knew the absolute truth. This belief brought both pride and an existential fear. To be better came with the implication that I must always act better, embodying an ideal that was unattainable. From a young age, I learned that my worth was tied to how perfectly I could live out these values, a lesson that left little room for mistakes, doubt, or vulnerability.

The sense of moral superiority ingrained in me as a child planted a deep and pervasive tension. While it gave me a sense of purpose, it also established an invisible but unrelenting pressure to maintain this elevated identity. Failing to meet these expectations didn’t just feel like a personal shortcoming—it felt like a betrayal of my faith, my community, and even God.

This internalized belief system left no space for imperfection. Vulnerability became a threat to the image I was expected to uphold. Showing weakness or admitting to struggles felt like admitting failure—not just as a person but as a Christian. My faith, which should have been a source of unconditional love, became a measuring stick against which I constantly fell short.

Over time, this pressure began to manifest in subtle but powerful ways. I found myself increasingly consumed by fear—fear of making mistakes, fear of being judged, and fear of falling short of the impossible standards that had been set for me. This fear seeped into every corner of my life, reinforcing an underlying anxiety that I could never fully escape.

In our community, the lines between right and wrong were drawn with sharp clarity, leaving little room for nuance or exploration. These rigid boundaries extended beyond moral teachings into the very fabric of our daily lives. From how we dressed to how we interacted with the world outside our community, everything was governed by a strict code of conduct.

I learned to navigate these expectations with careful precision, presenting a version of myself that aligned with what was demanded. Outwardly, I conformed, adhering to the ideals of righteousness and perfection that were expected of me. But inwardly, I wrestled with questions, doubts, and desires that didn’t fit neatly into the framework I had been given.

This dissonance created an internal conflict that became increasingly difficult to manage. On the surface, I appeared composed and devout, but beneath the surface, I felt fractured. The gap between who I was expected to be and who I truly was grew wider with each passing year, creating a sense of shame and self-doubt that I couldn’t reconcile.

As I grew older, the expectations of my faith community began to merge with my own internalized standards, creating a relentless cycle of self-judgment. Every thought, every action, every decision was scrutinized through the lens of what was “right” or “wrong.” The fear of falling short wasn’t just external—it became an internal chorus that echoed in my mind at all times.

This self-judgment was compounded by the belief that my worth was tied to how well I could uphold the ideals of my faith. When I stumbled, the guilt was overwhelming. It wasn’t just a matter of disappointing myself; it felt like I was failing my community and betraying God. This weight was suffocating, leaving little room for self-compassion or understanding.

The inability to reconcile my imperfections with the image I was supposed to project created an undercurrent of anxiety that became a constant in my life. I found myself trapped in a cycle of striving and failing, always chasing an unattainable standard that left me feeling inadequate and unworthy.

One of the most insidious effects of this upbringing was the way it isolated me from others. The belief that we were “better” than those outside our community created an invisible barrier that made genuine connection difficult. While I was surrounded by people who shared my faith, the underlying message of superiority made it hard to relate to others outside our circle.

This isolation extended to my internal world as well. The pressure to maintain an image of perfection left no room for vulnerability or authenticity. I learned to hide my struggles, presenting a façade that was acceptable to those around me but disconnected from my true self.

This disconnection was deeply lonely. I longed for understanding and acceptance, but the rigid expectations of my community made it impossible to share the parts of myself that didn’t align with their ideals. Over time, this loneliness became another layer of anxiety, reinforcing the belief that I was fundamentally flawed and unworthy of love.

Reflecting on these experiences, I can see how the teachings of my faith—while providing comfort and guidance—also laid the groundwork for my struggles with anxiety. The rigid expectations, the fear of judgment, and the pressure to maintain an image of perfection created a foundation of self-doubt and shame that I carried into adulthood.

These lessons were not taught with malice; they were the product of a community striving to live out its values in a challenging world. But their impact on me was profound, shaping how I viewed myself and my place in the world. The belief that I had to be better, stronger, and more righteous than everyone else left little room for vulnerability or growth, creating a cycle of fear and self-judgment that took years to unravel.

By sharing this chapter of my story, I hope to highlight the complexities of growing up in a faith community that demanded perfection while offering the promise of unconditional love. It is a paradox that shaped me in profound ways, teaching me both the power of faith and the dangers of expectations that leave no room for humanity.

Faith is often seen as a source of peace, yet it can also become a source of inner conflict when paired with rigid expectations and fear of imperfection. For me, the teachings of my conservative Christian upbringing created both comfort and constraint, instilling values that shaped my sense of self while also fueling the anxiety that I would carry into adulthood.

Reflecting on these experiences, I can see how the pressure to maintain an image of righteousness isolated me from others and from my authentic self. The expectation to suppress doubts, hide struggles, and strive for unattainable standards left me feeling fragmented and unworthy—a paradox that was both painful and deeply formative.

By sharing this part of my story, I hope to illuminate the complexities of faith and its role in shaping our inner world. It is not about rejecting faith but about recognizing the ways in which its rigid interpretations can create fertile ground for anxiety. True healing begins when we allow space for imperfection, embrace vulnerability, and reconcile our humanity with our beliefs.

The roots of anxiety discussed in this chapter highlight the complex interplay between the comfort of faith and the pressures of rigid expectations, which laid the foundation for self-doubt, fear, and isolation. These include:

1. Moral Superiority as a Burden: The expectation to embody an unattainable ideal of righteousness created constant pressure to maintain a perfect image.

2. Fear of Failure and Judgment: A pervasive fear of falling short, not only in personal endeavors but in faith, reinforced anxiety and self-doubt.

3. Rigid Boundaries of Right and Wrong: Strict rules left little room for exploration, growth, or self-expression.

4. Suppression of Vulnerability: The belief that weakness or struggles equated to failure stifled authenticity and emotional openness.

5. Internal Conflict of Identity: The dissonance between the outwardly devout persona and the inner struggles created a fractured sense of self.

6. Relentless Self-Judgment: The internalized need to meet faith-based ideals led to a constant cycle of scrutiny, guilt, and shame.

7. Isolation through Superiority: The belief in being “set apart” created invisible barriers to genuine connections with others, both within and outside the community.

8. Pressure to Conform: Adhering to the community’s rigid expectations left little room for individuality or personal exploration.

9. Loneliness from Inauthenticity: The inability to share true struggles fostered feelings of isolation and inadequacy.

10. Legacy of Perfectionism: The constant striving to meet unattainable standards created long-term patterns of fear and anxiety.

---

Share this Article